Skip to content
Heavenly Hocking

Where we actually eat

The hosts' own picks around Logan and South Bloomingville — pizza, barbecue, a converted car dealership, and the closest good coffee to the cabin.

September 2026 · from the Sleepy Bear Lodge guidebook, "Where We Actually Eat"

These are the places we go ourselves, in the words we use in the cabin guidebook.

Papa Dino’s Pizzeria — South Bloomingville

Our personal favorite. Get the Bianca pizza, the Firecrackers, and the garlic knots. Outdoor seating, gets busy on weekends — order ahead if you can. Closed Mondays.

Millstone Southern Smoked BBQ — Logan

The go-to after a long day of hiking. Brisket, ribs, cornbread bites. Expect a wait on Friday and Saturday nights — the bar seats fill faster than the tables.

58 West — Downtown Logan

Restaurant, brewery, and winery in a converted 1920s car dealership. Beer and wine flights, great patio, a step up if you want a nicer night out. Closed Tuesdays.

Hocking Hills Inn & Coffee Emporium — SR 664

The closest good coffee to the cabin and worth the stop. Great breakfast pizza, paninis, and gluten-free options. Opens at 7:30 AM — perfect on your way to a sunrise hike.